In Regards to Recent Events - Printable Version +- Forums - Open Redstone Engineers (https://forum.openredstone.org) +-- Forum: Announcements (https://forum.openredstone.org/forum-102.html) +--- Forum: Announcements (https://forum.openredstone.org/forum-7.html) +--- Thread: In Regards to Recent Events (/thread-14690.html) |
In Regards to Recent Events - Admin - 10-20-2018 Given the events the past week or so, Staff would like to lay out the events and the reason for our actions, inviting community input regarding these actions. It was brought to our attention that Greatgamer34 was contributing to Datawave, a community that DataCorruption is trying to start. We decided to talk with Greatgamer34, asking about his involvement in Datawave. Greatgamer34 denied involvement in Datawave. Another individual later came to Staff saying that Greatgamer34 posted private documentation from Staff’s private discussion board to Datawave just days before being asked about his involvement in Datawave. Greatgamer34 has also stated that he would release more once Datawave went public. One should also take into consideration that Greatgamer34 was actively trying to become Admin again. Doing so would result in Greatgamer34 obtaining much more information and that could be seen as a threat against ORE given his collusion with Datawave and his tendency to publicize private information. Upon finding this out, we concluded that the best course of action was to demote Greatgamer34 due to the lack of integrity and trust his actions portrayed. Meanwhile, DataCorruption denied receiving help and denied that these documents ever existed in Datawave. Greatgamer34, during his time as staff, implemented changes without consulting the rest of staff, such as making public statements without proper staff discussion, while DataCorruption, after some time being a moderator, decided to leave ORE in order to make his own community. The collaboration between these two former staff has lead us to make the decision to ban both DataCorruption and Greatgamer34 due to their negligence and overall denial of collusion. As always, Staff greatly appreciates community input. We love the ORE community and do not want it to become split by events such as this. We do not expect all of ORE to understand Staff’s reasoning for our actions, but we would appreciate an open mind when considering the situation. RE: In Regards to Recent Events - Legofreak - 10-20-2018 .../s RE: In Regards to Recent Events - Classified - 10-20-2018 somebody toucha my spaghet RE: In Regards to Recent Events - Classified - 10-20-2018 (10-20-2018, 05:50 AM)Legofreak Wrote: .../s somebody toucha my spaghet RE: In Regards to Recent Events - Matthew - 10-20-2018 somebody toucha my spaghet RE: In Regards to Recent Events - Classified - 10-20-2018 (10-20-2018, 02:42 AM)Admin Wrote: Given the events the past week or so, Staff would like to lay out the events and the reason for our actions, inviting community input regarding these actions. r/quityourbullshit RE: In Regards to Recent Events - Legofreak - 10-20-2018 ^^^^^ RE: In Regards to Recent Events - greatgamer34 - 10-20-2018 4 days to write a fokn ban report.... like if we honestly did something wrong the ban report should have been out the hour after we got banned..... but there wasnt a legitimate reason they were upset how I shared the ORE constitution with datawave and they claimed its a private file imagine if the US constitution was not allowed to be seen by its own citizens.... also the doc i shared wasnt even approved to be used by ORE so they werent even using it. This is all very cute and i loved your community but your administration is trash(besides pauk and digi). It was nice being a part of ORE for 5 years(wow that a lot of time) Also in response to capo, who seems to think the way i was elected 5 years ago was bullshit, why do you say that? Is it because I became Admin before you? I heard all of the shit that was said when i wasnt there and my assumptions that staff never liked me seem to be sprinkled with some truth. Also this is a fokn bullshit scumbag reason right here and after 4 days this is the best you could come up with" VThe collaboration between these two former staff has lead us to make the decision to ban both DataCorruption and Greatgamer34 due to their negligence and overall denial of collusion." You can ban a 5 year long member because their helping on another server? Also heres the link to the doc I shared: https://docs.google.com/document/d/1xduoJSsxABqiQ3TvaWL32CO5g5jgOxCuHdc4jTGjJRY/edit?usp=sharing RE: In Regards to Recent Events - greatgamer34 - 10-20-2018 oh and if they ddelete that post cuz it has the link, pm me and ill share it with you. - gg34 RE: In Regards to Recent Events - LordDecapo - 10-20-2018 It took 4 days cause you and data were spreading so much false information and shit talking that we had to all agree on something to say that didnt fall right into your two's childish games. If you handled yourself as an adult, none of this would have even needed to happen. Learn honesty and respect and maybe you could actually be a valid staff member in a community, just never this one again. RE: In Regards to Recent Events - LambdaPI - 10-20-2018 The reason you were banned was because you lied to staff about your involvement with datawave. You lost our trust. RE: In Regards to Recent Events - LordDecapo - 10-20-2018 (10-20-2018, 06:38 PM)LambdaPI Wrote: The reason you were banned was because you lied to staff about your involvement with datawave. You lost our trust. How can someone be kept in a staff team when they can not be trusted? RE: In Regards to Recent Events - greatgamer34 - 10-20-2018 banned because I lied to staff? I didnt even have a chance to say anything to staff before i was banned kek. You guys claimed someone shared private files, i didnt say shit because my files were public. the name of the doc as dodo pointed out was "ore stuff shareable". RE: In Regards to Recent Events - LordDecapo - 10-20-2018 (10-20-2018, 06:28 PM)greatgamer34 Wrote: 4 days to write a fokn ban report.... I love how this screams childishness and nothing but pure emotional rage. The only reason you think this staff is trash, is because we didnt bend over every time you wanted us to take it. Just because you want something, and the vast majority of other staff dont, doesnt mean we are a trash staff team, it simply means you do not know how to properly go about convincing people to go along with your plans and have a sheer unwillingness to compromise. RE: In Regards to Recent Events - greatgamer34 - 10-20-2018 Nah capo it seemed like when there was staff consensus it was you and nick that would shoot things down. Ive said it before and ill say it again. its nick> capo> admins>mods>everyone else> neo(love ya neo) RE: In Regards to Recent Events - LordDecapo - 10-20-2018 (10-20-2018, 07:01 PM)greatgamer34 Wrote: Nah capo it seemed like when there was staff consensus it was you and nick that would shoot things down. Ive said it before and ill say it again. its nick> capo> admins>mods>everyone else> neo(love ya neo) I would love to see this proof. Honestly. Cause from my memory, Nickster and I disagreed on the activity thing and Jer and I worked with You and Data on something that would make everyone happy. Then mentioned that we just wanted you to repost a new thread since the old one was so filled with edits and poll changes. You simply had to make a new vote and that would have been passed, either of you could have. There have been many votes that He and I have voted together and seperate, won and lost... There hasnt really been any major change or anything that was simply nick or I doing it all the way (that i can remember, i could be wrong, If you have examples I would like to know what they are). We discuss things, I may not make a post on the forums for some of the minor things I do, but i talk in slack and get ppls input till i know the majority has replied and is in agreeance, if not enough yeses, i just make a joke and forget about it. RE: In Regards to Recent Events - greatgamer34 - 10-20-2018 I could get ORE staff not wanting their staff to be active on another 'competing' server, so like demote me and shit whatever, but can you justify the ban? lmao like this is charades. RE: In Regards to Recent Events - JeremyG - 10-20-2018 I normally don't like to comment on stuff like this. However, you seem to really just ignore everything that's said and state the exact same things again, and again, and again. We demoted you because of the *complete* loss of trust(lying about stuff is probably the worst thing you could have done). We banned you because of the combination of this and the fact that you kept starting shit, just like you're doing here. You're making false accusations too. For example, we have had many, many things that both capo and nick didn't like still happen. (Also, the thing about "shareable", that's one of three documents that was shared and is the only one that had "shareable" in the title.) RE: In Regards to Recent Events - Phase - 10-20-2018 Just to clarify, I'm neutral in all this. I don't care what happens. I just like jumping around redstone creations. (10-20-2018, 06:37 PM)LordDecapo Wrote: If you handled yourself as an adult, none of this would have even needed to happen.Christ, I hate when people say this. No one here is acting like an adult. No one. Not you, not Data, not Nickster, not Great. Everyone here is acting petty and entitled. If you actually wanted to cooperate, you wouldn't be finding excuses to ban people or start your own servers. (10-20-2018, 06:38 PM)LambdaPI Wrote: The reason you were banned was because you lied to staff about your involvement with datawave. You lost our trust.Is this not ridiculous? This is a Video Game Server. This isn't politics, this is a bunch of nerds who like a video game. This "he said she said" bullshit is stupid. (10-20-2018, 06:41 PM)dodo_hacker Wrote: LOL, "private document" > "ORE stuff shareable.docx"If sharing documents was the reason for the ban, then the ORE staff did a terrible job at preventing it. I mean, come on, ORE stuff shareable? You didn't even name it "private" or something else to indicate it wasn't a public document? When I saw it, I instantly assumed it was public knowledge from the name. After skimming through it, it looked like your average set of server rules. Why this is such a hot topic is beyond me, but I don't understand why the ORE staff team didn't take measures to seal a document they were so worried about leaking. Who the fuck makes a shareable link to a Google Doc if they don't want it being shared? What's next, the CAS storing passwords in plaintext? If you didn't want people to leak it, you should have taken more care with who had access to it. And once it was "at DataWave", I didn't see much use of it. Some guys (all of which are/were ORE members) just discussed it, and saw it as a starting point for what a future DataWave "constitution" could be. Your future server rules and such being kept secret is ridiculous. To be honest, it just sounds like you needed an excuse to ban him. Why these documents are "private" is beyond me. I didn't read every word, but they didn't contain anything special. If they did, fine. They shouldn't have been shared, but they also shouldn't have been posted on Google Docs. I still think it's stupid that the rules of a Minecraft Server are being locked up. As for DataCorruption, why was he banned? That isn't explained here at all. Just because he denied knowing about the documents? Because he wanted to start his own server? Because he knows gg? He probably shouldn't have lied about having the documents if that's what happened, but banning some of the most active members on ORE is going to split things up. Again, I don't have a stake on either side. I'm just here to sprint jump on blocks. RE: In Regards to Recent Events - ElectroPlaysMC - 10-20-2018 all of this is bullshit RE: In Regards to Recent Events - Nickster258 - 10-20-2018 I would like to go ahead and contribute in this... discussion... a little bit and clarify the documentation shared. (10-20-2018, 06:31 PM)greatgamer34 Wrote: oh and if they ddelete that post cuz it has the link, pm me and ill share it with you.First off, "ORE stuff shareable" was a document made by Greatgamer34 and was already public upon initialization. This was following community backlash regarding his very unnecessary announcement that was not discussed with any other admin. Secondly, the two other documents Greatgamer34 fails to mention here were never, ever made public (That is until Greatgamer34 leaked them). These documents were drafts that the Staff team were working on in an attempt to have more documentation regarding our operations. These items were never completed and were thus never fit for public viewing. The "ORE Constitution - WIP" that everyone is saying should be a public document, was created long after ORE was founded and was only spawned in an attempt to clarify operations and rules. Since the document was never completed, it was never a basis for which we dealt with issues. It was a Work In Progress for a reason. Lastly, while this is just a "Video Game Server", something of such nature like sharing private, incomplete documentation is never, ever, in any circumstance, considered "minor". We treated this incident seriously as the Staff team and the community as a whole is built on trust, of which we no longer had with Greatgamer34. RE: In Regards to Recent Events - Classified - 10-21-2018 (10-20-2018, 06:38 PM)LambdaPI Wrote: The reason you were banned was because you lied to staff about your involvement with datawave. You lost our trust. He said he was not a staff member on Datawave. Nothing else. RE: In Regards to Recent Events - Classified - 10-21-2018 (10-20-2018, 09:17 PM)Nickster258 Wrote: I would like to go ahead and contribute in this... discussion... a little bit and clarify the documentation shared. Everyone is talking about GG but why was Data banned? can you explain? Because it seems like he was banned for no reason. RE: In Regards to Recent Events - Legofreak - 10-21-2018 you all need to chill out, shake hands and shut the fuck up. RE: In Regards to Recent Events - Matthew - 10-21-2018 I'm just chilling, listening to this, making a wp site, and felt it was time i finally make a serious comment and say goodbye. I'm assuming the reason i was banned is cause i said this. This was after gg posted the docs in dwave. I stepped down the day before gg posted them and had literally no idea these where private documents. I had no reason to suspect they where private in the first place. Nothing about them said non-shareable or "private" and they where made/shared by gg... w h a t t h e f u c k g u y s On the note of gg being involved... He was only involved as much as everyone else in the dwave disc until you banned him. The ONLY person who helped work on anything dwave before we both got banned was class. I made this clear to capo Quote:No one here is acting like an adult. No one. Not you, not Data, not Nickster, not Great. Everyone here is acting petty and entitled. If you actually wanted to cooperate, you wouldn't be finding excuses to ban people or start your own servers. - cool guy phase- agreed. Honestly this is all sad, pathetic, and so surreal. I can't believe ore staff acted this way. I didn't break any rules, the only thing I've done is step down and start working on a server. So idk what you want me to think i was banned for but it seems disingenuous to say its not cause i'm starting a competitor. I don't care about actually being banned cause i was leaving to start dwave anyway. I would have said it's sad to see ore lose its 2 most active members, but after this... welp.. later. goodbye ore (it was a fun 3 years) xoxo, data RE: In Regards to Recent Events - Trecar - 10-21-2018 You always demand of everyone to react to you in the most adequate and kind and cohenrently logical way possible yet you do none of that yourself while you pull of shady shit. I cannot pinpoint anything you did wrong in particular, yet your attitude is just garbage. you got voted mod by the community and left it alone as a thank you, and now you could even tear it apart. What a great person you are! I do not know why anyone in particular started this and I wish it would have never happened. Is it so hard to swallow your immense minecraft-server-pride and stop this bullshit? We are all idiots, and stating that does not make you any less of one. </Unwanted Opinion> RE: In Regards to Recent Events - LambdaPI - 10-21-2018 After consideration and responses from the community, the staff team has decided to overturn DataCorruption's ban. We hope that this is a step towards resolving this situation. RE: In Regards to Recent Events - greatgamer34 - 10-21-2018 (10-20-2018, 09:17 PM)Nickster258 Wrote: I would like to go ahead and contribute in this... discussion... a little bit and clarify the documentation shared. "ery unnecessary announcement that was not discussed with any other admin." literally says ideas, not new rules being implemented right now. Also that was a long time ago when i was quite naive and it was a post asking for community feedback. What did you really clarify on? People know what the other docs were, and the fact that they had little info compared to the larger doc. You guys also werent using any of these docs nor were they found in the RHB. Your assumption that I was sharing RHB data is flat out wrong and asinine. Plus these werent even official ORE docs used by ORE. What a joke nick RE: In Regards to Recent Events - PabloDons - 10-21-2018 (10-21-2018, 09:19 PM)greatgamer34 Wrote: literally says ideas, not new rules being implemented right now. Also that was a long time ago when i was quite naive and it was a post asking for community feedback. Conveniently ignoring the fact that this post was heavily edited after receiving backlash from staff, eh? I doubt you forgot what it said before then RE: In Regards to Recent Events - repeerc709 - 10-22-2018 <yeehaw> giddyup cowboy we're goin' on an adventure you don't have to be lonely at farmers only dot com idk man i just woke up like at 5:50 in the afternoon pls i don't wanna go on your stupid adventure dag nabbit jimmy you better get your ass some sleep i tell ya what </yeehaw> RE: In Regards to Recent Events - greatgamer34 - 10-22-2018 (10-21-2018, 11:02 PM)PabloDons Wrote:(10-21-2018, 09:19 PM)greatgamer34 Wrote: literally says ideas, not new rules being implemented right now. Also that was a long time ago when i was quite naive and it was a post asking for community feedback. Its been 4 or more years I dont remember what the first version said pablo. Are you implying that It would have been perfect the first time through? Lmao no. Ohno I edited a forum post to better suit what the ideas of the community were.................................. RE: In Regards to Recent Events - PabloDons - 10-22-2018 (10-22-2018, 01:50 PM)greatgamer34 Wrote:(10-21-2018, 11:02 PM)PabloDons Wrote:(10-21-2018, 09:19 PM)greatgamer34 Wrote: literally says ideas, not new rules being implemented right now. Also that was a long time ago when i was quite naive and it was a post asking for community feedback. "New rules that I will follow and I expect everyone else too as well" something along those lines. Memory is still hazy. I know there was a whole ordeal on slack about how you can't just make rules out of nowhere and your solution was to change it to say it's "suggestions" RE: In Regards to Recent Events - greatgamer34 - 10-23-2018 (10-22-2018, 02:58 PM)PabloDons Wrote:okay, and? I fucked up back then and imn pretty sure i acknowledged that. Also, this doc isnt used by ORE so like whats the big deal linking a doc showing how dumb i used to be? Like lmaooooo. Also this is my 1500th post bitches.(10-22-2018, 01:50 PM)greatgamer34 Wrote:(10-21-2018, 11:02 PM)PabloDons Wrote:(10-21-2018, 09:19 PM)greatgamer34 Wrote: literally says ideas, not new rules being implemented right now. Also that was a long time ago when i was quite naive and it was a post asking for community feedback. RE: In Regards to Recent Events - PabloDons - 10-23-2018 AND this proves that nothing has really changed. The big deal is if you would've had admin, you'd have access to passwords and full power to totally fuck up ORE. And you almost got it too, when you asked to step up. Obviously, you don't even hesitate to share potentially sensitive stuff. Imagine if you had passwords and ssh access. Hoo boy, Nick would probably call the police on your ass. Thank goodness you lost your temper and proved how unfit you are to be admin. Also, totally blowing it off as harmless or innocent isn't acknowledgment. RE: In Regards to Recent Events - greatgamer34 - 10-29-2018 Yo i wasnt really involved with datawave until after you guys blackballed me by ignoring my request to step up. I didnt send any RHB info to anyone. The only thing I shared and I admitted to sharing was the google doc stuff... SHARING GOOGLE DOCS THAT WERE MEANT TO BE PUBLIC, THAT WERE UNOFFICIAL, THAT WERE UNUSED, AND CONTAINED NO PERSONAL DATA IS HARMLESS. RE: In Regards to Recent Events - Hastumer - 10-30-2018 (10-23-2018, 08:32 PM)PabloDons Wrote: AND this proves that nothing has really changed. The big deal is if you would've had admin, you'd have access to passwords and full power to totally fuck up ORE. And you almost got it too, when you asked to step up. Obviously, you don't even hesitate to share potentially sensitive stuff. Imagine if you had passwords and ssh access. Hoo boy, Nick would probably call the police on your ass. Thank goodness you lost your temper and proved how unfit you are to be admin. Ima give my two cents to this, thought I already did but apparently not. But especially to this one post: I really don't think gg would have destroyed ORE if he got admin. What reason would he have? Like he may not always been the smartest guy when it comes to decisions, but he never came off as a person willing to destruct a whole server just because he can. RE: In Regards to Recent Events - Nickster258 - 10-30-2018 (10-29-2018, 11:53 PM)greatgamer34 Wrote: Yo i wasnt really involved with datawave until after you guys blackballed me by ignoring my request to step up. I didnt send any RHB info to anyone. The only thing I shared and I admitted to sharing was the google doc stuff... SHARING GOOGLE DOCS THAT WERE MEANT TO BE PUBLIC, THAT WERE UNOFFICIAL, THAT WERE UNUSED, AND CONTAINED NO PERSONAL DATA IS HARMLESS. This just shows us you do not fully understand your wrongdoing. You shared documentation that, while yes did not contain any private information (Other than personal names and potential account information), it was still just drafts and were never meant for public consumption until the drafts were completed. Honestly, had you asked to share the documentation, Staff would have been perfectly fine with it. Either way, this is a decision based on principle, not content. I feel that this point has been reiterated enough times for someone to understand, so I am going to step back from this discourse in hopes that you finally see our problem with your actions. RE: In Regards to Recent Events - LambdaPI - 10-30-2018 (10-29-2018, 11:53 PM)greatgamer34 Wrote: Yo i wasnt really involved with datawave until after you guys blackballed me by ignoring my request to step up. I didnt send any RHB info to anyone. The only thing I shared and I admitted to sharing was the google doc stuff... SHARING GOOGLE DOCS THAT WERE MEANT TO BE PUBLIC, THAT WERE UNOFFICIAL, THAT WERE UNUSED, AND CONTAINED NO PERSONAL DATA IS HARMLESS. The part about us ignoring your request to step up is just plain wrong. We discussed your rank in forums and in slack. I myself personally brought up your request to step up and pushed for an answer. RE: In Regards to Recent Events - PabloDons - 10-30-2018 Tfw you shared docs a day *prior* to asking to step up lololol (and data was quick to support it) |